Rent-to-Own: Pros and Cons

marketing213926
18 hours ago
3 min read

For buyers who want to become homeowners but aren’t quite ready for a traditional mortgage, rent-to-own can sound like an appealing middle ground. But while rent-to-own agreements can work in certain situations, they’re not right for everyone—and they come with important risks to understand.

If you’re considering rent-to-own in Southwest Michigan, here’s a breakdown of how it works, the potential benefits, and the drawbacks you should know before moving forward.

What Is Rent-to-Own?

A rent-to-own agreement allows a tenant to rent a home with the option (or obligation) to purchase it at a later date—usually within one to three years.

Most rent-to-own contracts include:

A lease period (you live in the home as a renter)
An option fee paid upfront (often non-refundable)
A portion of monthly rent credited toward the future purchase
A predetermined purchase price or pricing formula

These agreements are privately negotiated and vary widely, so contract details matter a lot.

The Pros of Rent-to-Own

1. A Path to Homeownership Without Immediate Financing

Rent-to-own can help buyers who need time to:

Improve credit scores
Save for a down payment
Stabilize income or employment

You get the chance to live in the home while working toward qualifying for a mortgage.

2. “Try Before You Buy”

Living in the home allows you to:

Test the neighborhood
Understand commute times
Experience seasonal changes (important in Michigan)

This can reduce the risk of buyer’s remorse.

3. Locked-In Purchase Price

Some agreements lock in today’s purchase price, which can be helpful if home values rise in markets like Kalamazoo, Portage, or Mattawan.

4. Potential Rent Credits

A portion of your monthly rent may go toward the future purchase, helping build funds toward ownership.

The Cons of Rent-to-Own

1. Higher Monthly Costs

Rent-to-own payments are often higher than market rent, and rent credits don’t always equal dollar-for-dollar equity.

2. Non-Refundable Fees

If you don’t end up buying the home—due to financing issues or a change in plans—you may lose:

The option fee
Any rent credits

This is one of the biggest financial risks.

3. Maintenance Responsibilities

Many rent-to-own contracts shift maintenance and repair responsibilities to the tenant—costs typically handled by a homeowner, not a renter.

4. Financing Isn’t Guaranteed

Rent-to-own does not guarantee mortgage approval. If your credit, income, or lending guidelines change, you could still be unable to buy when the lease ends.

5. Complex Contracts

Rent-to-own agreements are not standardized. Some favor the seller heavily, and vague or poorly written terms can put buyers at risk.

Is Rent-to-Own Common in Southwest Michigan?

Rent-to-own arrangements are less common in Southwest Michigan compared to traditional home purchases, and many advertised options are offered by private sellers or investors. Because of this, it’s especially important to work with a trusted real estate professional and an attorney before signing anything.

In many cases, buyers who believe rent-to-own is their only option may actually qualify for:

FHA or USDA loans
Low down payment programs
First-time buyer assistance

Rent-to-Own vs. Buying Traditionally

For many buyers, buying traditionally—possibly with assistance programs—can be safer, more affordable, and better long-term than rent-to-own.

A knowledgeable local agent can help you:

Explore all financing options
Compare rent-to-own vs. traditional buying
Avoid costly mistakes

Final Thoughts

Rent-to-own can be a useful tool in specific situations, but it’s not a shortcut to homeownership—and it carries real risks. Before entering any agreement, it’s essential to understand the contract, evaluate your financial readiness, and explore all available alternatives.

The Keefer Fischer Real Estate Team, led by Kerry Keefer Fischer, helps buyers across Southwest Michigan make informed decisions based on their goals—not pressure or gimmicks. If you’re considering rent-to-own or wondering if buying sooner is possible, we’re happy to help you review your options.